Italian restaurants

Casa Mia

4.3 408 reviews 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM 205 Main St, Hurleyville, NY 12747, United States

Discover this place

When it comes to Italian dining in Hurleyville, NY, Casa Mia stands out as a local favorite. Situated at 205 Main St, this charming restaurant has garnered praise for more than just its food; it's the engaging staff that truly elevates the dining experience. Customers rave about the attentive and friendly waitstaff, who create a warm and welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like a family gathering.

Patrons have fallen in love with dishes like the broiled pork chops, acclaimed for their flavor and served alongside fresh green beans. The portions here are generous, ensuring that you'll leave satisfied. Reviewers like Tialisa Whipple and Mary Makovic highlight the great quality and value offered at Casa Mia, with many returning for the consistently excellent meals.

The decorations may benefit from a bit of modernization, as noted by Danny G, but the quality of the food more than makes up for it. Be it a casual meal or a special occasion—like Kerry Sullivan's graduation celebration—Casa Mia has proven to be a reliable choice for memorable dining experiences.

Overall, if you're in the area, a visit to Casa Mia is a must. With delicious food, a warm environment, and standout service, it truly captures the essence of Italian hospitality.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Locals
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Casa Mia before visiting.

Reviews for Casa Mia

4.3

408 reviews

100%

27%

11%

Review highlights

Based on 408 reviews

Casa Mia is widely regarded for its exceptional service and warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Reviewers consistently highlight the attentiveness and friendliness of the staff, which contributes significantly to a welcoming dining experience. The restaurant offers generous portion sizes with a focus on fresh, high-quality Italian cuisine that appeals to both locals and visitors. While some mention that the decor could benefit from updates, it does not detract from the overall positive impression. Casa Mia also stands out as a preferred venue for special occasions, praised for its accommodating and helpful event planning. Overall, the combination of excellent food, attentive service, and a comfortable environment makes Casa Mia a favored choice in the Hurleyville area.

Tialisa Whipple

Jun 10, 2025

I have to say the best thing about this place is the staff. The food was good the atmosphere fine but the waitstaff was exceptional. Very attentive, funny without being obnoxious and friendly. Our waitress made us feel like family. I love that! This restaurant is literally a stones throw from my house so it's a go to whenever I don't want to cook. There are other restaurants just as close, but I choose Casa Mia. You can tell they are all working hard at building a successful business and the staff reflects it. My favorite dish here is the broilded pork chops with a side of fresh green beans.

Mary Makovic

May 27, 2025

Very nice family place w great portions and great all around choice for Italian food and more.

Danny G

May 17, 2025

Place has always been my favorite decor can use some upgrading but the food is out of this world excellent fresh and portions are huge better than any place in area

Mr. T

Apr 21, 2025

Great food, amazing service nothing but an outstanding time. Must visit if your near by.

Kerry Sullivan

Apr 05, 2025

Casa Mia Hurleyville hosted my graduation party and it was amazing! They let us arrive early to decorate.The food was delicious, the staff was wonderful and so helpful, and everything that went into the planning was easy. The cost was surprisingly reasonable. I will definitely consider them again Thank you for making a wonderful evening go smoothly!

Darth Reign

Mar 23, 2025

Excellent food family style plates for most food I saw coming out everything looked really good and what we had was great my plate had a lot of scallops and shrimp. Veal Parmesan was really good to I recommend if your in the area

Terence M. Perkins

Mar 18, 2025

The father/son duo are classy and warm-hearted....the father makes the best drinks and the son is a class act...like Dad

Donna Lann

Mar 14, 2025

Ate there 3 days in a row while upstate visiting family. Had to get my NY Italian fix handled!! Casa Mia pasta dishes and pizza are amazing, should have brought home 10 to-go dishes of Rigatoni alla vodka!! My favorite! The host was amazing, really catered to us!! Will definitely be back by on out next trip up!! Thank you all so much!!!